- Radiohead . Hail To The Thief
- Bonnie Prince Billy . Master And Everyone
- The New Pornographers . Electric Version
- The White Stripes . Elephant
- Clearlake . Cedars
- The Raveonettes . Chain Gang Of Love
- Black Rebel Motorcycle Club . Take Them On, On Your Own
- Mogwai . Happy Songs For Happy People
- Grandaddy . Sumday
- The Stratford 4 . Love And Distortion
- The Kills . Keep On Your Mean Side
- The Be Good Tanyas . Chinatown
- Frankenixon . Depth Perception
- The Yeah Yeah Yeahs . Fever To Tell
- Sam Roberts . We Were Born In A Flame
- Damien Jurado . Where Shall You Take Me
- The Drive-By Truckers . Decoration Day
- A Silver Mt. Zion . This Is Our Punk Rock, Thee Rusted Satellites Gather & Sing
- The Fire Theft . The Fire Theft
- One Mile North . Minor Shadows
Biggest disappointments of the year:
- The Dandy Warhols . Welcome To The Monkeyhouse
- Elbow . A Cast Of Thousands
- The Folk Implosion . The New Folk Implosion
- Matthew Good . Avalanche
Likely would have made the top 20, but haven’t arrived in the mail yet:
- My Morning Jacket . It Still Moves
- Guided By Voices . Earthquake Glue
- The Fiery Furnaces . Gallowsbird’s Bark
- Explosions In The Sky . The Earth Is Not A Cold Dead Place
- Snow Patrol . Final Straw