A few hours ago we saw The Wind That Shakes The Barley (tiff | imdb) at the Elgin. It was as compelling as advertised, and I felt none of the unevenness that other reviews have described. I thought the swings between the quiet conversations — portents of what was waiting to erupt — and the bursts of violence mirrored the Irish conflict itself.
My two main problems were that I couldn’t understand most of what was said in the first 15 minutes, and that I was left wanting to know more about what happened…what led to the beginning of the story, what followed after, and what happened in parallel. Neither of these were really faults of the film; the sound was a bit too low and the accents very thick, and my own knowledge of the roots of the IRA are lacking. I also thought that the ending seemed to almost slip by, that it wasn’t as powerful as it might’ve been, but I suppose that’s Loach’s style.
The analogy to present-day Iraq (or any other occupied country) is obvious, but the world could do with a bit of blinding obviousness now and then. It presented a new side of such conflicts to me though, one that seems as wicked as it is unfair:Â powerful countries hold all the cards in situations like Iraq, or Ireland, or Palestine, or colonial India. The reasons for occupying another country can be the most outrageous and unfair in the world; it matters little. The occupied citizenry, faced with violent oppression and having only the choice between peaceful resistance and violent opposition, usually opt to respond in kind; those opting for violent reprisal have no “official” military to muster and so are branded terrorists, whether deserving of the title or not. The occupying force then has moral authority to continue with the occupation.
History often remembers occupiers as imperialist aggressors and “terrorists” as revolutionaries, unless the revolutionaries becomes as corrupted by violence as the occupiers, in which case both sides find themselves in a morass, a cycle of violence with no morality or means of breaking free. No means, that is, except the spilled blood and declining memory of wasted generations.
[tags]tiff, toronto international film festival, the wind that shakes the barley[/tags]