There’s a Substack post I’ve been sitting on for almost two years now. Its title is “The American Century”, quoting a famous editorial by Henry Luce (who we’ll get to in a minute), and it was written by Dan Gardner.
It was written in early December 2004, not long after Donald Trump was re-elected president of the United States. I think most people can remember their despair in the immediate aftermath of that election. Gardner summarizes is here:
On January 20th, the new president will be a man who has never shown the slightest interest in the vision of the United States as a “shining city on a hill.” A man who praises strongmen and dictators, bullies friends and allies, and sneers at “shithole countries.” A man who — like some 18th century mercantilist teleported to the 21st century — thinks imports create poverty and tariffs prosperity. A man who feels nothing but contempt and hostility for the post-Second World War Pax Americana, the American-forged and American-led international order that, however flawed, delivered an unprecedented era of human flourishing.
The world as we have known it since 1945 is swaying, as if in an earthquake, threatening to topple.
You know all that. So today I want to go back to 1941 and look at some passages taken from an essay written by Henry Luce. I think you’ll agree that the contrast between Luce’s words then and what we are hearing now is both illuminating and profoundly sad.
Gardner then breaks down Luce’s 1941 essay in which he implores America to step up as a stabilizing, progressive force in the world and abandon the isolationism that seized the US until Pearl Harbor. There’s quite a lot — I’d encourage you to read the whole thing — but it loops back toward its central thesis:
“America as the dynamic center of ever-widening spheres of enterprise, America as the training center of the skillful servants of mankind, America as the Good Samaritan, really believing again that it is more blessed to give than to receive, and America as the powerhouse of the ideals of Freedom and Justice – out of these elements surely can be fashioned a vision of the 20th Century to which we can and will devote ourselves in joy and gladness and vigor and enthusiasm.”
That Good Samaritan line comes up earlier too, when he says this: “We must undertake now to be the Good Samaritan of the entire world. It is the manifest duty of this country to undertake to feed all the people of the world who as a result of this worldwide collapse of civilization are hungry and destitute.” It’s hard to fathom, but this man was a Republican.
Anyway, I’ve sat on this post because saying anything about it two years ago felt futile. MAGA had won again. The Good Samaritan had turned heel. I had no optimism for the country to our south. Neither did Gardner at the time, judging by one of his final paragraphs:
And today? The United States is wealthy beyond what even Henry Luce could have imagined. And yet it is inconceivable that any Republican — literally any Republican — would write something like “we must now undertake to be the Good Samaritan of the entire world” except perhaps as a mocking paraphrase of the views of people they despise.
So why revisit the post? Well, after the recent midterm elections provided just enough of a spark to make me revisit this post, I’m slightly hopeful that America may once again find its way back to what it once was: imperfect certainly, but far better than the creature it’s become. So I share Gardner’s nervous wish: “We can only hope it doesn’t take a depression and a world war for Americans to learn again.”